With all that being said there are other points that made me want to leave shiism
I don't see any good reasons that you mentioned.
What would be only possible reasons that could of the potential of being good is if you go through all various proofs and arguments for Shiism and refute those. Show you've understood the arguments, the counter-arguments to them, and counter to counter arguments, and so on and so forth, till you show a conclusion.
Start with why you understand the two legacies the Prophet left the nation differently then Shias. Talk about hadithal thaqalain etc.
The fact is, you stated things that are all irrelevant to whether one should be Shiite or not. They are all irrelevant.
May God save us from following our caprice and make us enjoin the truth.
Of course because your biggest Sheikhs believing in Tahrif is not a good reason .. yeah i forgot Shias dont care about Quran only about <<the walking and talking qurans >> lol just like the ismailis
It is precisely not a good reason because our "biggest" Sheikhs are not an authority. The ones that passed hadiths passed hadiths, the ones who teach teach what they teach, but at the end of the day, the two things the Prophet told us to hold on to is his book and his family.
Secondly, while I don't believe in Tahreef, I don't believe in bullying people in believing in the Quran is uncorrupted by threatening their state of faith. Indeed revelations before us all corrupted, so why Quran is an exception, has to be something to be found out.
To say anything like Prophethood ended or its states it's protected, is circular reasoning. The Prophethood ending assumes there is no Authority that safeguarded and is going to bring it back, and stating it states it's protected assuming it means protected in the sense no tahreef takes places among the people, would have to rely on the fact no tahreef has taken place in it in the first place.
Naturally, witnessing the superior nature of Quran and guidance of whole Quran with respect to all it's parts is no easy task, and not something anyone should be bullied into.
I believe the subtle nature of it's verses, it's flow, etc, all proves it to be a miracle.
However when you say things like "What kind of God let's his book be corrupted, and his leader hidden", I think you yourself don't believe in Quran, because Quran shows that has happened in the past many times.
One could say God could of protected all his revelations. But then you can say, it's only necessary to protect his last revelation.
Then you would have to argue why it's necessary and not protect it in the sense of being able to bring it back by Imam Mahdi alongside its interpretation.
And I believe there is good arguments as to why God would protect it before the coming of the Imam Mahdi and all the way up to that and after, but I believe they are subtle arguments.
And Sunnis are far removed from understanding those subtle arguments as they don't even understand basic premilaries to it.
And Quran is clear guidance with clear proofs, because it has clear proofs for all that it asserts and manifests.
You haven't even understood is most repeated clear proofs with regards to it's essential structure, so let a lone more subtle things like as to why it would be safeguarded outwardly and inwardly.
25 Replies
10061 Views
July 13, 2016, 01:03:42 AM