TwelverShia.net Forum
Off Topic Discussion => General Discussion => Topic started by: Najamsethii484 on November 02, 2017, 11:48:02 AM
-
Salaam everyone im ex sunni and want to know about name of abu hurairahs father because it doesnt written anywhere is it something fishy with his birth?
-
^
Very strange any Shia would talk about Abu Hurayrah's (RAA) father [upon which there are many different Aqwaal by the way], when 'Ali's (RAA) father was named Abd Manaf!!! Talk about perpetuating false views based on mere names!!!
If one wants to insinuate anything based on this faulty reasoning, first start with 'Ali and leave Abu Hurayrah alone!!!
-
Salaam everyone im ex sunni and want to know about name of abu hurairahs father because it doesnt written anywhere is it something fishy with his birth?
The name of his father is Abd Ghanm. This is reported by Al-Fallas, Ibn Abi Al-Dunya, and others.
-
^
Very strange any Shia would talk about Abu Hurayrah's (RAA) father [upon which there are many different Aqwaal by the way], when 'Ali's (RAA) father was named Abd Manaf!!! Talk about perpetuating false views based on mere names!!!
If one wants to insinuate anything based on this faulty reasoning, first start with 'Ali and leave Abu Hurayrah alone!!!
thanks for your nawasib comments where did Imam Ali AS come from i asked about abu hurayrah fathers name is it so difficult to answer it nawasib boy and Imam Ali As father name was Abu Talib AS and mothers name was Fatima Bint Asad SA and abu hurarirah father name is uknown and mothers name also because he is father of cats im sure that any of your guys so called companions of Prophet Muhammad Saww who was hypocrites actually had any father or mother and thanks for saying that Imam Ali AS belongs to Shia Islamic community and not you guys you guys only say that you believe in him but you dont inside your heart is hatred for Ahlulbayt AS
-
Salaam everyone im ex sunni and want to know about name of abu hurairahs father because it doesnt written anywhere is it something fishy with his birth?
The name of his father is Abd Ghanm. This is reported by Al-Fallas, Ibn Abi Al-Dunya, and others.
tell me more jokes this name is not even on internet its false name i searched it so many times
-
^
Very strange any Shia would talk about Abu Hurayrah's (RAA) father [upon which there are many different Aqwaal by the way], when 'Ali's (RAA) father was named Abd Manaf!!! Talk about perpetuating false views based on mere names!!!
If one wants to insinuate anything based on this faulty reasoning, first start with 'Ali and leave Abu Hurayrah alone!!!
thanks for your nawasib comments where did Imam Ali AS come from i asked about abu hurayrah fathers name is it so difficult to answer it nawasib boy and Imam Ali As father name was Abu Talib AS and mothers name was Fatima Bint Asad SA and abu hurarirah father name is uknown and mothers name also because he is father of cats im sure that any of your guys so called companions of Prophet Muhammad Saww who was hypocrites actually had any father or mother and thanks for saying that Imam Ali AS belongs to Shia Islamic community and not you guys you guys only say that you believe in him but you dont inside your heart is hatred for Ahlulbayt AS
Try using commas to break up your points.
-
^
Very strange any Shia would talk about Abu Hurayrah's (RAA) father [upon which there are many different Aqwaal by the way], when 'Ali's (RAA) father was named Abd Manaf!!! Talk about perpetuating false views based on mere names!!!
If one wants to insinuate anything based on this faulty reasoning, first start with 'Ali and leave Abu Hurayrah alone!!!
thanks for your nawasib comments where did Imam Ali AS come from i asked about abu hurayrah fathers name is it so difficult to answer it nawasib boy and Imam Ali As father name was Abu Talib AS and mothers name was Fatima Bint Asad SA and abu hurarirah father name is uknown and mothers name also because he is father of cats im sure that any of your guys so called companions of Prophet Muhammad Saww who was hypocrites actually had any father or mother and thanks for saying that Imam Ali AS belongs to Shia Islamic community and not you guys you guys only say that you believe in him but you dont inside your heart is hatred for Ahlulbayt AS
Try using commas to break up your points. are you a english teacher ? abu hurairahs father name please??????
-
tell me more jokes this name is not even on internet its false name i searched it so many times
This is a screenshot from Al-Fallas' book (p. 224).
(https://preview.ibb.co/bUnHqw/20171102_141415.jpg)
It is not my problem if you do not have these sources and did not find it online.
-
^
Very strange any Shia would talk about Abu Hurayrah's (RAA) father [upon which there are many different Aqwaal by the way], when 'Ali's (RAA) father was named Abd Manaf!!! Talk about perpetuating false views based on mere names!!!
If one wants to insinuate anything based on this faulty reasoning, first start with 'Ali and leave Abu Hurayrah alone!!!
thanks for your nawasib comments where did Imam Ali AS come from i asked about abu hurayrah fathers name is it so difficult to answer it nawasib boy and Imam Ali As father name was Abu Talib AS and mothers name was Fatima Bint Asad SA and abu hurarirah father name is uknown and mothers name also because he is father of cats im sure that any of your guys so called companions of Prophet Muhammad Saww who was hypocrites actually had any father or mother and thanks for saying that Imam Ali AS belongs to Shia Islamic community and not you guys you guys only say that you believe in him but you dont inside your heart is hatred for Ahlulbayt AS
I am only using the logic you used against the Companion (RAA) and applying to 'Ali (RAA), whose father's name was after a false idol, as Abu Talib was not his real name. If this Shia logic is used against Abu Hurayrah (RA) and other Companions (RAA), I say those who are symbols of Shiaism should not be spared, as simple as that.
As for the sources not being in the Internet, I suggest you take real Islamic instruction and learn the sources of proof for Sunnism before coming here with irrelevant rants. Your hatred of us should not make you so arrogant that it prevents you from learning our religion with our scholars.
-
why was he called father of cats?
-
why was he called father of cats?
First of all, are you satisfied with the answer that I have given you?
-
^
Very strange any Shia would talk about Abu Hurayrah's (RAA) father [upon which there are many different Aqwaal by the way], when 'Ali's (RAA) father was named Abd Manaf!!! Talk about perpetuating false views based on mere names!!!
If one wants to insinuate anything based on this faulty reasoning, first start with 'Ali and leave Abu Hurayrah alone!!!
thanks for your nawasib comments where did Imam Ali AS come from i asked about abu hurayrah fathers name is it so difficult to answer it nawasib boy and Imam Ali As father name was Abu Talib AS and mothers name was Fatima Bint Asad SA and abu hurarirah father name is uknown and mothers name also because he is father of cats im sure that any of your guys so called companions of Prophet Muhammad Saww who was hypocrites actually had any father or mother and thanks for saying that Imam Ali AS belongs to Shia Islamic community and not you guys you guys only say that you believe in him but you dont inside your heart is hatred for Ahlulbayt AS
Try using commas to break up your points. are you a english teacher ? abu hurairahs father name please??????
So many question marks? Has Ameen returned under a new username?
-
So many question marks? Has Ameen returned under a new username?
Not Ameen himself but his twins :)
-
why was he called father of cats?
First of all, are you satisfied with the answer that I have given you?
its a name you just founded by yourself i didnt find it anywhere in books or internet so its only a joke i think he didhave a unknown father its 100% true
-
Scrolll up. I posted a screenshot.
-
i find this as fake as abu hurairah searched that books name even it didnt came up where did you get so fake books from its not even most authentic books of sunnis like sahih muslim or bukhari?
-
^
It is not our fault if you cannot find our books, not everything that you cannot find is fake by default even if that is the Shias' wish. Try to become more academic in the future, if possible.
-
Al Bukhari and Muslim are not sources for biographical information.
Unfortunately for you, nobody doubts the accuracy and attribution of Tareekh Al Fallas to its author, so surely, your opinion is irrelevant.