Welcome to the forums bro.
It is good to see more French brothers being active in this field. =]
The narration does seem acceptable to me. It isn't like what the liar Adnan Ibrahim says. They are not all Imams.
The first narrator is Alaa' bin Abdul Jabbar NOT Abdul A'ala bin Abduljabbar, as Adnan said. Al Nasa'ee says: Laysa bihi ba's (he is not bad), and Abu Hatim said: Salih (decent).
More importantly, the narration is unclear. It doesn't say what Abu Huraira was talking about. It doesn't say that he hid hadiths or anything. There is no context. Of course, opponents will use this to assume the worst for Abu Huraira.
These are good evidences brother. Well done.
I asked my shaikh about the hadith means that Abu Huraira asked for his money, which is his right, since he was vice-governor of Madinah.
Ibn Musayyab, on the other hand, refused to take money from the government.
Ok it's liked to his job of vice gouvernor? can you says more please?
You know there is the hadith when Abou Hourayra says " the prophète (puh) give me 2 earthenwares if I distribute the second, people would have killed me"
Scholars says that hadith is linked to hypocryte gouvernors of kuraysh and if he talked he was killed.
Ok it's liked to his job of vice gouvernor? can you says more please?
Je n'ai rien de plus à dire. C'est juste une théorie.QuoteYou know there is the hadith when Abou Hourayra says " the prophète (puh) give me 2 earthenwares if I distribute the second, people would have killed me"
Scholars says that hadith is linked to hypocryte gouvernors of kuraysh and if he talked he was killed.
C'est possible parce qu' il avait toujours prié Allah qu'il ne viva pas jusqu'à l'année 60H, dont Yazid serait le caliphe.
Because Adnan Ibrahim quoted " It's Marwan Al hakim who says to Abou Hourayra "don't speak !"!!
If why I would like to have the entire hadith when Abou Hourayra says "If I want to denounced them I will do it"
and where I can find it.
Sorry but... can you forbid this topic to shia please?
Hello.
Nobody respond me?
in connection with Jewish influence. I have that.
Shia says.
-Acording to Ibn Saad " One man has interchanged hadith of Kaab el Akhar and hadith Ot the messenger (psl) and this man reported from Abou Hourayra"
-And there is this Hadith about the creation in 6 days reported by Muslim.
But Al Bukhari says this hadith come from Kaab El Akhbar.
It's over?
Honestly I'am very disappointed . Nobody respond me.
Honestly I Have test this technic against Shias and it very very very effective.
Shia don't want talk with me, they are afraid because I show them that Abou Hourayra knew "El GHAIB" (invisible) , grace Messenger( puh), more than all shia's books assembled.
Like you know "EL GHAIB" is very important for Shia. But it's Abou Hourayra and Hudayfa who was especialised of it. not el Kulayni or "their imam".
Why nobody respond?
Without you I could do this refutation, but with your help it will be the ultimate refutation.
I'm not here to act the clown.
Brother,
Are you asking about Kaab alahbaar?
I am sorry as well akhi. Sometimes I don't have time to help others because I am doing too many things at once. I am currently writing a book, translating it, and reviewing another one. So please excuse me.
Inshallah other brothers can participate in this discussion.
If someone know how improve "visual indentity" for pdf-format please contact me.
If someone know how improve "visual indentity" for pdf-format please contact me.
What do you mean by visual identity?
Learn to work with LateX, the best way to create pdf's. It does have a little bit of a steep learning curve, but it pays dividends.
You don't have to download anything to start learning, overleaf.com does everything online