TwelverShia.net Forum
Sunni Shia Discussion Forum => General Sunni-Shia => Topic started by: Hani on November 08, 2014, 04:04:09 PM
-
Salam `Aleykum,
Added a new update to the old Inheritance of Prophets article, check the Q&A section, the order of writing one's Will:
http://twelvershia.net/detailed-research-on-prophetic-inheritance/
This answers the question of "Did Rasul-Allah (saw) make a mistake by not writing his Will?"
I've written this some time back, I decided to add it now as I think it's complete.
-
Added an Index to the Q&A section so members can check the questions/objections we answered:
1. Can the narration of a single man (khabar ahad) restrict qur’anic meaning?
2. Why did the wives inherit the land of khaybar?
3. Why did the wives get to keep their houses?
4. Isn’t inheriting the kingdom proof that prophets leave money as inheritance?
5. Did sulayman inherit a thousand horses from his father?
6. Can prophet-hood be inherited?
7. Does the fact that only sulayman was mentioned as heir mean anything?
8. Does the verse {and we were given from all things} mean he inherited money?
9. Are there narrations proving that prophets never offered an inheritance of money?
10. Did dawud have other children than sulayman?
11. What significance do the words {and inherits from the house of ya`qoub} have?
12. What kind of knowledge would be left as inheritance?
13. Did zakariya fear his prophet-hood would be stolen?
14. Do these words {make him, o my lord! One with whom thou art well-pleased!} Make no sense if asking for a successor in other than money?
15. Can prophet-hood be attained by du`a’?
16. Did `ali or fatimah ever use the verses of sulayman and yahya to prove that prophets leave inheritance?
17. The terms “mawali” & “waliya” in the verse of zakariya, do scholars agree on its meaning?
18. Is asking the lord to send a prophet to the people rude?
19. What did yahya receive from zakariya?
20. How did the shia imams explain the two verses according to authentic shia narrations?
21. Did prophet adam (as) give inheritance?
22. Did prophet ishaq (as) leave inheritance?
23. Do prophets live a luxurious lavish lifestyle?
24. Prophets inherit in the bible and other religious books?
25. The prophet (saw) gave fadak to fatimah?
26. Did fatimah bring two witnesses to prove fadak belongs to her?
27. What was the fay’ of the jews in madinah used for? What was the fay’ of khaybar used for including fadak? What was the rest of the land of khaybar taken by force used for?
28. What about the hadith of abu dharr that says leaders will monopolize the wealth from the fay’?
29. Were there any servants to be inherited by the household?
30. What were fatimah and al-`abbas asking abu bakr for?
31. What were al-`abbas and `ali asking `umar for?
32. Did `ali, al-`abbas and fatimah understand the hadith of the prophet (saw) as abu bakr did?
33. Did abu bakr and `umar agree with the household on how khums is spent?
34. In conclusion, is fatimah entitled to receive anything from fadak?
35. Is the fay’ supposed to be under the control of abu bakr and he divides it?
36. What is the opinion on the narration where fatimah replies to abu bakr with “you know best”?
37. Anything that prophets leave as charity cannot be inherited?
38. Did `ali accuse abu bakr of being dishonest and treacherous?
39. Is the anger of fatimah in this case dangerous?
40. Mursal al-sha`bi is it rejected or accepted?
41. Did the prophet (saw) give some lands as gifts to certain men, if so why did abu bakr not confiscate them?
42. Did the three caliphs inherit the prophet’s (saw) ring?
43. The prophet’s (saw) clothes were inherited?
44. What did the prophet (saw) leave behind?
45. How can ahlul-bayt eat from sadaqah?
46. Did prophet muhammad (saw) inherit?
47. Did the messenger (saw) wish for his family wealth?
48. How do you explain the verses of fay’ in surat al-hashr?
49. Why was fatimah angry?
50. Is not writing a wasiyyah(will) a mistake on the part of prophet muhammad (saw)?
51. Was abu bakr more knowledgeable about the prophet (saw) than his daughter?