Umar married Umm Kulthoom bint Ali - ayotollah Sistani

[iceman]

Not discussing taqiyyah here.
Look at the idiot
Imam says Umar married umm kulthum
The idiot choses not to believe it
But imam made a correct statement also
You are sick .
Again i am losing my temper over the purposeful crap that you r putting forth
Imam said umar married umm kulthum
Now it is necessary clarifying that .
You are really spitting whatever breads in your mind.

Nope my dear you are the one doing all the dance here and i am bored with that by now.
You Posted in every single website you could dig up. And of no avail
First you say umar is portrayed a bad way
I refuted
Then you say , dates are confusing i refuted
Now your only lone excuse is marraige requires her to be much grown up.
my challenge, respond to this only instead of writing newspapers, show us one Shia scholar who says parents can't give children in marraige before puberty.
The same khoei who didn't mind saying sunnis are najis (impure) the same khomayni who barked on aaisha (r.a) didn't care about Muslim faternity but ,when he was asked about can a man enjoy a child before puberty he suddenly becomes thoughtful of Muslim faternity ,which sunni scholar says ok pentrating a girl between thighs ,for khomayni to imitate sunnis for faternity .?

Look at the idiot Imam says Umar married umm kulthum"

Lol. Did the Imam say that? Why did he say it? What was the reason for saying it? What was the circumstances at the time? What situation was he facing and the conditions he was up against? Non of this counts or matters. And why aren't all the Shia scholars and people accepting this and taking it at face value?

"But imam made a correct statement also
You are sick"
 
Correct due to the circumstances at the time and the situation he was in and the conditions he was facing. Why didn't Umar marry Zaynab? Zaynab was older than Qalsoom. Why don't we have a story that Umar married Zaynab binte Ali?

Because Zaynab was popular in history due to her being active in Karbala. If you need your make a story then you've got to make it in a way and use characters that are less known and not that popular, not being in the limelight for the story to stick and sell.

Why don't we have a story like Ibne Saba married the daughter of Ali or Muawiya married the daughter of Ali or something like that? 😊 Why Umar? Why only Umar and not anyone else mentioned? Why only the one who is accused of burning the door? 😊

It's a flaming coincidence isn't it that the one who is actually accused of burning the door and injuring Fatima, whether he did or he didn't is another thing, he is the one of all people who is named and linked in the tale of marrying Fatimah's daughter?

Is it so it can be used as a counter argument that if Umar really and truly burned the door and injured Fatima then later on in life why the on earth did Ali marry his daughter to him 😊 What a coincidence. Fits perfectly, doesn't it 😊

[MuslimK]

Shia early books all prove and establish the marriage between Omar (ra) and Umm Kulthum bint Ali (ra) but most of them today deny that it ever happened just like they deny the existence of the daughters of the Prophet (saw).