Hearing of Abi Nad'ra A'bdi from ABU Huraira r.a

[Muhammad Habib]

I was reading that imam Baheqi said that it is not proven that Abi Na'dra abdi  have sama' or hearing from Abu Huraira ra
but Imam D'habi says that he has...
I m confused ... I want to know that whether Abi Nad'ra 's hearing from Abu Huraira is proven or not? 

[Farid]

I'll check it out and get back to you inshallah.

[Nader Zaveri]

Assalaamu `Alaykum,

al-Dhahabi doesn't confirm the samaa`ah, he says in his Tarikh al-Islam the same statement of al-Bayhaqi, without refuting it. Although, he does say in his Rijal books that Abu Nadrah al-`Abdi narrated from Abu Hurayra, but that isn't conclusive proof that he believed in the Samaa`ah.

[Moin]

Al-'Alai did say that he heard from Abu Hurairah, however he could be wrong. Most of hisnarrations throughAbu Hurairah does have a narrator between them and those which are directly from Abu Hurairah is through 'an'ana. It seems Abu Nadhrah deserve a space in Tabaqat al-Mudalliseen according to the methodology of those who name Irsal Khafi as Tadlees. Allah knows best

[Muhammad Habib]

Thanx brothers for your beneficial feedback..
@farid bro what's your opinion on this matter

[Lebanese Habib]

Thanx brothers for your beneficial feedback..
@farid bro what's your opinion on this matter

Salamu3alaikum everyone, sorry I didn't know there was a Habib on this forum.