TwelverShia.net Forum

Sunni Shia Discussion Forum => Hadith-Rijal => Topic started by: Farid on June 29, 2014, 11:21:46 AM

Title: Hanafi and Irsaal
Post by: Farid on June 29, 2014, 11:21:46 AM
Shias attack Sunnis with disconnected hadiths, saying that Hanafis accept disconnected hadiths. I'm not a Hanafi and I do not know what their response is to this.

Thoughts?
Title: Re: Hanafi and Irsaal
Post by: Ebn Hussein on July 19, 2014, 03:16:25 AM
A Hanfi talib al 3ilm should give us a good answer. What about contacted the brothers from Hanafi Fiqh channel/youtube (they are actively refuting Rawafid).
Title: Re: Hanafi and Irsaal
Post by: HughSlaman on July 19, 2014, 02:32:56 PM
Quote from: Farid on June 29, 2014, 11:21:46 AM
Shias attack Sunnis with disconnected hadiths, saying that Hanafis accept disconnected hadiths. I'm not a Hanafi and I do not know what their response is to this.

Thoughts?

The Shias who say this should present evidence from reliable Hanafi sources. We all know what the Shias do when quoting Bukhari and Muslim, and we can't expect that they would be better at quoting Hanafi usul al-fiqh principles.

Also, would the Shias who use such disconnected evidence also accept, say, the sahih mursal report from Sha'bi which tells us that Sayyida Fatima, may Allah be pleased with her, was pleased with Sayyiduna Abu Bakr, Allah be pleased with him, just before she died? If they want us to accept the disconnected report from Zuhri about the alleged conflict over Fadak, then we have even stronger reason to accept this narration from Sha'bi which tells us the conflict was resolved.
Title: Re: Hanafi and Irsaal
Post by: Farid on July 19, 2014, 04:16:25 PM
I've actually seen it sourced brother Hugh, which is why the matter is confusing.

Also, yeah, the Shias are obviously using double standards.
Title: Re: Hanafi and Irsaal
Post by: HughSlaman on July 19, 2014, 04:50:59 PM
Do you have the source? Is there a link?
I found this from Kuwait University:

http://pubcouncil.kuniv.edu.kw/jsis/home.aspx?id=8&Root=yes&authid=380# (http://pubcouncil.kuniv.edu.kw/jsis/home.aspx?id=8&Root=yes&authid=380#)


The Authoritativeness of the Mursal (Incompletely Transmitted) Hadith in the View of Scholars of Usul and Hadith
Auther : Dr. Saber Nasr Mustafa
Title: Re: Hanafi and Irsaal
Post by: Farid on July 19, 2014, 05:04:44 PM
Nah, I have a book on the fiqhi sects and their views of mursal narrations.
Title: Re: Hanafi and Irsaal
Post by: Muhammad Habib on July 25, 2014, 07:26:16 PM
Is it true that Imam Nauvi mentioned in Sharah Muhad'ib ,
Sufian Thori, Malik and Imam Auza'e took mursal as A proof and
the first one who rejects Mursal Narrations was Imam Shafi'e ... ?