TwelverShia.net Forum

Sunni Shia Discussion Forum => Hadith-Rijal => Topic started by: MuslimK on November 11, 2015, 02:28:24 AM

Title: Narrations of Alī ibn Abī Ṭālib & his progeny in Sunni books
Post by: MuslimK on November 11, 2015, 02:28:24 AM

I am copying here an old but useful post (http://islamic-forum.net/index.php?showtopic=14190&p=131856) of brother Hani.

---

Praise be to God I was one of the first to download this MAJOR book by the respect brother Faysal Noor (http://www.fnoor.com/main/default.aspx).

Title:
الرد الجلي على شبهة عدم رواية أهل السنة عن آل علي
al-Radd al-Jalee `ala Shubhat `Adam Riwayat Ahlul-Sunnah `an Aal-`Ali
“The manifest answer to the doubt of Ahlul-Sunnah not narrating from the family of `Ali”

This is a 5,562 pages book of Hadith that contains ONLY narrations from `Ali’s (ra) family and his progeny, from the classical books of Ahlul-Sunnah.

The following members may Allah have mercy on them are included:

-`Ali ibn abi Talib.
-Fatima bint Sayyiduna Muhammad (SAWS).
-al-Hassan bin `Ali bin abi Talib.
-al-Hussayn bin `Ali bin abi Talib.
-`Ali Zayn al-`Abideen.
-Muhammad al-Baqir.
-Ja`far al-Sadiq.
-Muhamamd ibn al-Hanafiyyah.
-`Umar bin `Ali bin `Ali bin abi Talib.
-Fatima bint `Ali bin abi Talib.
-al-Hassan bin al-Hassan bin `Ali bin abi Talib.
-al-Hassan bin Muhammad bin `Ali bin abi Talib.
-Fatima bint al-Hussayn bin `Ali bin abi Talib.
-`Abdullah bin Muhammad bin `Ali bin abi Talib.
-Zayd bin al-Hassan bin `Ali bin abi Talib.
-Muhammad bin `Umar bin `Ali bin abi Talib.
-`Umar bin Muhammad bin `Ali bin abi Talib.
-Ibrahim bin Muhammad bin `Ali bin abi Talib.
-`Abdullah bin al-Hassan bin al-Hassan bin `Ali bin abi Talib.
-Ibrahim bin al-Hassan bin al-Hassan bin `Ali bin abi Talib.
-Zayd bin Ja`far bin Muhammad bin `Ali bin Muhammad bin Ja`far bin `Isa bin `Ali bin al-Hussayn bin `Ali bin abi Talib.
-al-Hussayn bin Zayd bin `Ali bin al-Hussayn bin `Ali bin abi Talib.
-`Umar bin `Ali bin al-Hussayn bin `Ali bin abi Talib.
-Musa bin Ja`far bin Muhammad bin `Ali bin al-Hussayn bin `Ali bin abi Talib.
-Muhammad bin `Amro bin al-Hassan bin `Ali bin abi Talib.
and apparently others…

The total of narrations of Ahlul-Bayt in the classical books of Ahlul-Sunnah is around 25,713 narrations.

NOTES: The author does not take into consideration: Authenticity, repetition or abrogation as the goal is simply to collect all narrations from the family of `Ali (ra) [Not the family of the Prophet (SAWS) as that would include many other companions].

DOWNLOAD LINK: http://www.fnoor.com/main/articles.aspx?article_no=8106#.Vj_a2164nEY

I still haven’t browsed through it thoroughly to know if they are Ahadith Marfu`ah to the Prophet (SAWS), or Athar from Ahlul-Bayt? or Both? I think it’s both… so,

`Ali ibn abi Talib (ra) = 15,266 narrations.
Fatima bint al-Rassul (SAWS) = 260 narrations.
al-Hassan ibn `Ali (ra) = 715 narrations.
al-Hussayn ibn `Ali (ra) = 589 narrations.
`Ali bin al-Hussayn (rah) = 1,228 narrations.
Muhammad bin `Ali (rah) = 2,953 narrations.
Ja`far bin Muhammad (rah) = 2,030 narrations.
Zayd bin `Ali bin al-Hussayn (rah) = 107 narrations.
ect…

Either-way, you can download it and see, it’s 13 volumes.

Title: Re: Narrations of Alī ibn Abī Ṭālib & his progeny in Sunni books
Post by: Hani on November 12, 2015, 01:11:36 AM

I found a lot of narrations in our books from `Ali and his children that are not in this book, probably because the author used some software to collect these narrations and software is not very reliable. So whatever are the numbers above, know that it's more.