The Implications of Inconsistency in the Hadith of the Shia

[MuslimAnswers]

Salam alaykum,

Important article that has been uploaded, a translation of Shaykh Tahaa Karaan's piece on the matter:

https://www.basair.net/implications-inconsistency-hadith-shia/

(If this already been linked to somewhere on this forum, the admins can merge this into that thread)

[Rationalist]

Its a good intro. We need articles that get past the intros.

[MuslimAnswers]

Its a good intro. We need articles that get past the intros.

Even if it is an introduction, it is necessary, we know that what seems second-nature to some of us may still be very new information to most Sunnis - the same with the series of lectures Shaykh Karaan gave about the Twelver religion a few years ago, it is perhaps introductory at a certain level, but it still caused quite a stir nevertheless.

[zaid_ibn_ali]

If shia sources are based in the 400 usul which in turn are comprised of the asl of zurara etc, then I would like to know more about these asl. Their authenticity, details etc.

How do these compare with the asl of the students of the four sunni imams?

[Hani]

While the article may be basic, many points are quite advanced and may not be understood by a beginner. I specifically mean the scandals of the so called four emissaries.