The Status of Abu Huraira

[MuslimK]

بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم

The Status of Abu Huraira

In this short chapter, we list some of the praise that Abu Huraira has received from his contemporaries in order to dispel any doubts that surround his character. We have relied on authentic narrations and will point out if there are any weaknesses or defects if there are any.

[Ameen]

Lets start off with reality and facts. When did he accept Islam???

[Optimus Prime]

Lets start off with reality and facts. When did he accept Islam???

The article contains certain facts. Have you read the article?

[Husayn]

Lets start off with reality and facts. When did he accept Islam???

When did Ibrahim bin Hashim?

[Ameen]

No answer. Nothing new!

[Ameen]

Lets start off with reality and facts. When did he accept Islam???

When did Ibrahim bin Hashim?

No answer. Instead a counter question!

[Hani]

Lets start off with reality and facts. When did he accept Islam???

"Abu Hurairah embraced Islam only some days before Khaibar"
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abu_Hurairah

[Husayn]

Lets start off with reality and facts. When did he accept Islam???

When did Ibrahim bin Hashim?

No answer. Instead a counter question!

No, rather, all the questions are already answered here:

http://islamic-forum.net/index.php?showtopic=14843

I don't think a single Shii criticism of Abu Hurayrah (ra) was left unrefuted in that thread.

[Husayn]

Infact, they were refuted so thoroughly that I reached the following conclusions:

1. The Shii system of 'ilm al-rijaal and hadith are a total joke (i.e. any Shii opinions on these matters are totally worthless).

2. The Shii rijalists are blatant hypocrites - they are willing to make baseless accusations against Abu Hurayrah (ra), but when the same accusations are made against their own primary narrator (Ibrahim bin Hashim) they will seek endless excuses to refute them.

Seriously, read that thread from beginning to end (if you have a brain) and you will be much better off for it.

[Hani]

The link you gave is too advanced for him.

[Hadrami]

Im sure he never heard the name Ibrahim ibn Hashim. Ameen the Bot doesnt read any proofs even when its from shia sources, remember

[MissyB786]

If Ameen claims to know the answer why doesnt he answer rather than trying to ask a question for which he is going to disagree with anyways.