TwelverShia.net Forum
Sunni Shia Discussion Forum => Hadith-Rijal => Topic started by: Hani on October 29, 2014, 02:05:50 PM
-
al-Salamu `Aleykum,
This is just done, enjoy:
http://twelvershia.net/2014/10/24/the-teachers-of-the-imams/
Any questions can be posted here.
-
BarakAlah feek Akhee, that was indeed interesting and beneficial.
-
Jazaak Allahu Khairan bro Hani.
This is a very subtle but destructive argument against Imamah. It's almost too simple to be honest.
Why is a divinely appointed infallible narrating from fallibles? :o
-
Not just ANY fallibles bro Husayn, but ultra-Nasibi fallibles (acc. to Shiism!). Alhamdulillah the internet and a few soldiers of Allah are shredding the Rafidi religion big time.
-
The most important point is that some of their teachers were relatively unknown small time teachers. I find that very interesting.
-
Err, why do INFALLIBLE Imams need teachers in the first place? Not even an infallible can teach an infallible who is guided by Allah from day one.
-
Why wasn't Zaid bin Aslamrah) listed as teacher of Ali ibn Hussain(rah) ?
Imam Dhahabi records some reports according to which, Ali ibn Hussain(rah), also known as Zain al-`Abideen, used to sit in the majlis of Zaid bin Aslam. So once Nafe’ bin Jubayr said to him,”You are Sayyid and you are sitting in the majlis of a slave.” to which he replied, ”knowledge is to be taken, no matter from where it comes”. Siyar (4/388).
-
Im not saying I have collected every Shaykh, just whatever I could find based on who they narrated from, I must not have found a Hadith for `Ali from Zayd.
-
Could you look in siyar then, at the given reference, if you find a report, or even the statement of Ali would be sufficient.
"knowledge is to be taken, no matter from where it comes"