TwelverShia.net Forum
Sunni Shia Discussion Forum => Imamah-Ghaybah => Topic started by: fgss on June 29, 2017, 05:37:18 PM
-
Assalam o Alaikum,
http://www.shiachat.com/forum/topic/235050475-imam-ali-and-taqqiyah
They have seriously nothing to quote from nahjul balagha in their defense except sermon 3 (which indeed is a fabrication). Can someone more knowledgeable make a specific aritcle refuting the sermon 3 and other related narrations in a more academic manner so in future they even not dare to use this fabricated sermon as well.
Some related narrations to this sermon are mentioned in above link.
Jazak Allah.
-
Walaikum Salam,
Check this:
http://nahjul-balagha.net/shaqshaqiya-grading/
-
Even Sermon 3 doesn't reference Ghadir, Dawah Ashira or the fact that he was divinely appointed. It just states that Ali was sidelined and how was more qualified to lead the ummah. The anology Ali uses is how an axis fits a mill so perfectly that's how he was the ideal candidate to lead. However this doesn't mean he was divinely appointed followed by 11 Imams.
-
Even Sermon 3 doesn't reference Ghadir, Dawah Ashira or the fact that he was divinely appointed. It just states that Ali was sidelined and how was more qualified to lead the ummah. The anology Ali uses is how an axis fits a mill so perfectly that's how he was the ideal candidate to lead. However this doesn't mean he was divinely appointed followed by 11 Imams.
I used these same arguments there but got no answer. In fact got a tag of nasibi etc. This is how they usually react when truth became clear to them. Their final cards are taqqiyah and accusing others of being nawasib.