Challenged Issued to Shiachatters

[Aba AbdAllah]

Can you show me just ONE for the sake of curiosity?

I am talking about what is established as Tawatur in Sunni sources like hadithal thaqalain with it's various verision along with Man Kunti Mawla Fa hadaa Aliyan Mawla which give context to each other in meaning,

I found all claims answered on Sunnah website. Hadeeth thaqalain along with ghadeer event here:
https://youpuncturedtheark.wordpress.com/2015/02/19/hadeeth-al-thaqalayntwo-weighty-things-the-correct-understanding-and-a-spot-on-perspective-of-sunnis/

as well the Salawat upn the family of Mohammad being just like the Salawat upon the family of Ibrahim and the comparision.

Salawat issue dealt here:
https://youpuncturedtheark.wordpress.com/2012/05/23/salawat-series-the-fact-about-salawatdurood-regarding-which-shias-are-unaware/

I know you don't have the same view of Auli-Mohammad as us, but the Quran makes a distinction between one type of family of Prophets with another,

This was dealt here
https://youpuncturedtheark.wordpress.com/2010/10/30/deception-of-shias-by-categorizing-the-ahlebayt-of-prophetspbut/

[Hani]

Brother link in the near future I may ask for your skype so we can have a chat about everything related to `Ali's Imamah.

[Sheikh]

That "debate" was embarrassing.


I would like to say that Farid won, but it's kind of hard to say he won when the debate never really took place.  It looked more like Abu Hadi was avoiding the topic of the debate.

[Farid]

Believe it or not, I entered the chatroom on Shiachat and some of them bashed me for accepting the debate, accusing me of looking for an "easy win"... As if I knew of Abu Hadi's level.

[Khaled]

Believe it or not, I entered the chatroom on Shiachat and some of them bashed me for accepting the debate, accusing me of looking for an "easy win"... As if I knew of Abu Hadi's level.

They always do that when their side loses (which is always).

[Sheikh]

Well, I can give you a tip: if they have a picture of Khomeini or Khamenei as their display photograph, they know next to nothing about Islam; Sunni or Shia.

[Hani]

Well yes, this is a lame picture, very childish.

[Furkan]

Great analyse sheikh :p

[Hadrami]

So the debate which never started because of a confused shia eventually ended

I say confused, because first he said ghadeer is clear cut proof

[ You are not allowed to view attachments ]

and then after wasting so much time he said he also need hadith other than ghadeer to proof that it is a clear cut proof..... As always, only confused people becomes a shia. At least he realised & stop, otherwise faridov will probably eat him alive on ghadeer

[ You are not allowed to view attachments ]

May Allah bless faridov for having so much patience with such a people

[Farid]

Seems like you enjoyed yourself akhi Hadrami. =)

[MuslimK]

He talks about wasting time but he was the one who wasted all this time.

[Sheikh]

Prediction: The debate will go on a while until it becomes clear the Shi'i debater can't win, so the moderator will close the thread because "its a useless debate."

Your prediction was 100% accurate, ya akhi. Subhan Allah.

[Rationalist]

The 12er Shia are like jellyfish. They have no backbone. They just like to sting you by antagonizing Sunni Islam, but when it comes to defense they got nothing.

[sameer]

started with his so called "logic", directly jumps towards the Quran in next post, and finally ends on a Hadith, wht else u could expect frm this shia who was not following his own rule..

[Hadrami]

Seems like you enjoyed yourself akhi Hadrami. =)

Looking at another shia with arsenal of proofs and never use it is funny bro. All those proofs are made of plastic anyway

[Furkan]

Dude, atleast plastic can stand still, shiism can't

[shiaali]

I can prove shia imamate with logic. I don't need Sunni hadith. Can I take this challenge?

[Ibn Yahya]

I can prove shia imamate with logic. I don't need Sunni hadith. Can I take this challenge?

"Logic". I can guarantee that whatever you come up with will be illogical and full of contradictions and things that don't add up.

[Hani]

I can prove shia imamate with logic. I don't need Sunni hadith. Can I take this challenge?

You can open a thread and argue whatever you wish bro.

[shiaali]

I can prove shia imamate with logic. I don't need Sunni hadith. Can I take this challenge?

"Logic". I can guarantee that whatever you come up with will be illogical and full of contradictions and things that don't add up.

you mean like how sunni say ghayba contradict imamate? I believe in infallible imams, i am obedient to imam. shia obey imam. it is not contradiction because sunni also obey the prophet without meeting him. Or do sunni have to see him in person to obey him?