The Qur'an is above all. It is the scale, the measuring device. Are you saying it is absolutely necessary for me to accept anything and everything that my scholars say, or whatever is in the four books?
No but it is absolutely incumbent upon you to accept what is "authentically" narrated from your "infallible" Imams (ra). Otherwise, you are an apostate.
By the way, it sounds very sweet to say that Qur'an is the scale and the measuring device. It is sad, however, to then not be able to substantiate your usool-e-deen (Imamah) from the Qur'an.
Yes Zakah is in the Qur'an but not the punishment you mentioned concerning Zakah.
Can we agree, as per Surah Al-Baqarah, disbelief in a portion of the book is to actually disbelieve?
Also it doesn't say in the Qur'an that Fatima's right to inheritance was forfitted or ceased.
There was no inheritance, hence, the Qur'an does not have to spell it. The Qur'an explicitly states that Fay cannot owned by an individual or a group of individuals, therefore, there is no room to discuss inheritance unless you suffer from some mental disease or were raised upon blind hatred.
Prove to me from the Qur'an the punishment of not paying Zakah, the government having the right to take Zakah off people and the families and relations of Messengers and Prophets have no right to inheritance what so ever.
I have done better and you know it! From the "infallible" Imams (ra) who are hujjah upon you, I proved that the punishment meted out in the case of Malik was justified and with one verse of the Qur'an, I completely shut down the entire discussion on Fadak, whether you see it as Fatima's (ra) inheritance or a gift given to her. Your offspring cannot inherit what you do not own; similarly, you cannot gift someone something you do not own.
I have no problem with you denying the Qur'an and your own "infallible" Imams (ra); in fact, I expected nothing better. However, do not insult our intelligence by claiming that you follow the two.
No, your exact words were "prove Imamah from the Qur'an' those were your exact words. The bracket statement came in later. I've already proven this. Will forward the evidence again.
You are a liar! I have always accepted your "proofs" for the sake of argument only to refute you using your own "proof". That pattern is consistent from my side.
Can you prove from the Bible that Jesus wasn't killed and neither was he crucified? The Bible is book of Allah, did Allah mention in the Bible that Jesus won't be killed or crucified. What you'll witness is just a drama, a fiction. It won't be reality. Can you prove this from the Bible.
For the highlighted part, I must say that calling you a dimwit is an insult to dimwits. You never cease to amaze me. I mean, how low can you go?
You wanted proof of Imamah from the Qur'an and I gave it to you and you accepted it because there was no denying it
That "Imamah" actually poses more problem for the Imamah you claim to follow. I have given you the reasons. Go read them again and try to refute those points.