Revisited | The Concept Of Imamah - *Taqiyya/Pressure

[Qamar Farooq]

[MuslimK]

Watch @19:40 how that one single Hadith agitated the Shia debator. He tried to prevent them from reading it. Even though I think it was the same Hadith he half-quoted earlier.

[MuslimK]

Around 26 minutes the Shia claim that if he accepts that Ali gave Baya then it was Taqqiya.

These people just follow their desires. Play the Taqqiya game whenever evidences are brought against them. 

[MuslimAnswers]

Around 26 minutes the Shia claim that if he accepts that Ali gave Baya then it was Taqqiya.

These people just follow their desires. Play the Taqqiya game whenever evidences are brought against them. 

This game can be played by anyone else, and ad infinitum: Like, why did the Prophet give the sermon at Ghadir? Anyone can say it was for Taqqiyah, that it has no doctrinal or even Fadhai'il relevance whatsoever - the reason can be made up a posteriori. Even others can direct this towards other Ahadith or the Qur'an itself, and make a mockery of Prophethood.