Umar ibn al-Khattab and Abu Bakr ibn abi Quhafa at Khaybar

[Hadrami]

Having said that, brother Hani was making an assessment as per your methodology. 

True, if we are using shia's twisted standard & version of history, there will be no other conclusion than that Ali was a very weak & incompetent leader, guide, husband, father etc. Alhamdulillah us, majority of muslim dont subscribe to shia bollywood stories, hence our Ali, the real non fictional Ali will always be seen as one of the greatest hero.