OBJECTION!
WHY ABOU HOURAYRA HAS NOT DIRECTLY GAVE THE NAMES OF BADS GOVERNORS?
-----------------------
The rouwaybida Adnan Ibrahim has said
" Abou Hourayra will be punished because he has not given the names of bads governors"-----------------------
The most accurate view is that Abou Hourayra knew the names of Hypocryte.
May be he has the same list like Houdeyfa El Yemam or he has an "another list"
And like you know it's was prohibed to reveal the names of hypocryte.This advice is supported by Al Qurtubi:
Imam al-Qurtubi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
Our scholars said: What Abu Hurayrah did not disclose, and feared that he may be persecuted or killed because of it, has to do with matters of tribulations and statements identifying individual apostates and hypocrites Al-Haafiz Ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
The scholars interpreted the vessel that he did not disclose as referring to hadiths which stated the names of bad rulers and governorsLike it was forbidden to give the names of hypocrytes Abou Hourayra did like Houdeyfa El Yaman. He has just suggested indirectly who were hypocrytes.
Houdeyfa did that with Omar. And Abou Hourayra did that with his students like Said Ibn Mussayb.
Like you know the issus of Hypocryt is principal for shia propaganda. If this view is confirmed it will be bombshell because how Abou Hourayra can be an Hypocryte while the Messenger saws has given him secrets about Hypocrytes???
That confirm the high level of Abou Hourayra for the Messengers saws . Abou Hourayra was his confident.
source:
https://islamqa.info/en/147659ANOTHER POINTSaid Ibn Mussayb didn't like Hypocrytee and Banu Ommeya. And he followed all advices from Abou Hourayra to prevent bad govenors and hyporcytes like we see in this naration.
Narrated Abu Huraira:
Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said,
"This branch from Quraish will ruin the people." The companions of the Prophet (ﷺ) asked, "What do you order us to do (then)?" He said, "I would suggest that the people keep away from them.''Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 3604
But after the Abu Hureira death, Mouawiya came to Medina and Said Ibn Mussayb reported:
Narrated Sa`id bin Al-Musaiyab:
When Muawiya bin Abu Sufyan came to Medina for the last time, he delivered a sermon before us. He took out a tuft of hair and said, "I never thought that someone other than the Jews would do such a thing (i.e. use false hair). The Prophet (ﷺ) named such a practice, 'Az-Zur' (i.e. falsehood)," meaning the use of false hair.Sahih al-Bukhari 3488
For me it's the proof that Muawiya was not an hypocrit