TwelverShia.net Forum
Sunni Shia Discussion Forum => Sahabah-AhlulBayt => Topic started by: Yoshua ibn Zahoor on July 03, 2017, 11:26:49 PM
-
Rafidha accuse Talha ibn ubaidullah ra intended to marry Aisha ra however this is the the Talha ra who is from Ashre mubashira But the Talha ibn ubaidullah ibn masafe who wanted to marry is not the same Talha ibn ubaidullah who is from Ashre mubashira and the full name of Talha ibn ubaidullah who is from Ashre mubashira is Talha ibn ubaidullah ibn usman please if somebody can provide refrence for it it will be highly appreciated!
-
This is their refrence
-
The fact is that he is not the same Talha ibn Ubaidullah ibn Uthman ibn Amr ibn Kaab al-Tamimi al-Qarshi, who was present in the battle of Jamal, and who was from the ten persons who are guaranteed paradise, rather he is Talha ibn Ubaidullah ibn Musafa’ ibn Ayyaz ibn Sakhar ibn Aamir ibn Kaab al-Tamimi al-Qarshi. We read in usudul Ghaba he was named as Talha al-Khair as well like Talha ibn Ubaidullah, who is from the ten (who are guaranteed paradise) and this lead to confusion amongst people, and they said : He is the one regarding whom the verse of Quran “” was revealed, and this is because he said : If the Prophet (saw) died, I will marry Ayesha, and this is wrong, and this is why a group of people from the ahl al-tafsir thought that he is Talha ibn Ubaidullah, the one from the ten (who are guaranteed paradise) when they saw that he is Talha ibn Ubaidullah al-Tamimi al-Qarshi, and that he is a Sahabi as well.
Usudul Ghaba, Vol. 5, p. 122
Taken from
http://www.twelvershia.net/2013/04/25/respone-to-what-does-mother-of-believers-really-mean/