That's what you think. As far as I'm concerned I've answered your questions, addressed your points and responded to each and every comment you've made and concern you've put forward.
At best, you have offered us our own answers. In other words, you are telling me what I believe. I have no qualms with my beliefs; I have an issue with your beliefs. The essence of Imamah is violated by none other than the Imams (ra). There is not a single person who contradicts Imamah more thoroughly than the Imams (ra) themselves.
What you cannot and will not do is offer reconciliation between Shi'i beliefs and the actions of the Imams (ra).
We are not hesitant or concerned. We've been dealing with such accusations and arguments based on propaganda for the last 1400 years. Nothing bothers or shocks us.
In other words, you have gone mind numb! You cannot, or refuse to, see how the Imams (ra) went against every clause within Imamah (which are laid down by Shias).
You speak immature. Do you even know what failure is? Let me give you an example according to your own understanding again.
The inability to protect your own wife is failure. I feel sorry for the one who will marry you.
FAILURE. Do you believe in the coming of Mahdi? I'm sure you do as a Sunni. Why is he going to come and what is he going to do? Because the world will be filled with evil and injustice and he will fill it with justice and fairness.
So according to your theory Muhammad s.a.w and his final message along with his efforts failed otherwise why would the world fill with unfairness and injustice and what would be the need for Mahdi.
The Holy Prophet (saw) accomplished and succeeded in his mission. The very fact that one of his descendants, who is also from his Ummah, will establish fairness and justice is a testimony to the Holy Prophet's (saw) success because Imam Mahdi (as) will establish justice by re-implementing the Sunnah of the Holy Prophet (saw). Furthermore, this descendant will bring back justice, NOT INTRODUCE JUSTICE, by emulating the Holy Prophet (saw).
In summary, the Holy Prophet (saw) not only lived and succeeded in his mission but his followers will continue upon it and the only source of justice is following and implementing the Sunnah of the Holy Prophet (saw).
You, on the other hand, cannot even accept Muawiya as your leader when it was your 2nd "infallible" Imam (ra) who made him the leader of the Muslims!
Will you, as a Shi'i, dare emulate Imam Hassan's (ra) action and accept Muawiya as your leader?
Now let us see which actions of the Imams (ra) can you implement and follow.
1. They never declared their Imamah. Will you follow them in not preaching and following Imamah? You won't!
2. They could not establish their control upon the Ummah (even when they had the Caliphate). Will you accept and admit this reality, let alone abide by it? You won't!
3. Keeping Shi'i expectations and beliefs in mind, the Imams (ra) did the exact opposite of what was expected of them. Will you, for example, accept Muawiya as your leader as did Imam Hassan (ra)? Or will you concede Fadak? You won't!
4. The Imams (ra) contradicted each other in action. Will you uphold one's actions over the other's? You won't!
As you can see, upholding the "sunnah" of the Imams (ra) will force you into negating Shi'ism!
See how ridiculous your theory and understanding is. 😊
See how absurd your analogy was!