Well if that was the case and the matter was as crystal clear as that then they're wouldn’t have been an issue, would there?
Quantity but no quality! You offered nothing as rebuttal to negate my assertion that the Imams (ra) themselves contradicted the concept of Imamah (thereby shattering its credibility) more thoroughly than anyone else.
I put forward and explanation and ask to answer and you disregard it. Once again what was the belief and faith of the author/writer of Al-Kafi? And did he believe in absolutely everything he has in his book? If the matter was as simple and as straightforward as you've said,
Where did Al-Kafi come from? As a matter of fact, just a side-note, the compiler of Al-Kafi believed in the authenticity of the reports.
then where does the belief and faith of the author/writer (Al-Kulayni) go?😊
The compiler of Al-Kafi went to people who upheld their own nafs above Islam. In fact, these people were those whom the Imams (ra) cursed.
Exactly, so where did this unfairness and injustice come from? Is Caliphate going to be the actual cause? And it's going to be at the absolute peak and high, that's how worse it's going to get before the coming of Al Mahdi.
So according to your theory the Holy Prophet (saw) accomplished and succeeded in his mission, so what's going to or is going wrong if the Holy Prophet (saw) accomplished and succeeded in his mission?😊
To put it another way, since you like to play dumb, the fact that Sunnah has to be re-implemented is a testimony to the success enjoyed by the Holy Prophet (saw).
If you were to establish the success model suggested by Wilayah, what will you implement? Do you even have a model? The only two "infallible" Imams (ra) who had the Caliphate did everything that you despise. One gave up the Caliphate, both made some sort of peace with Muawiya (with varying degrees in the outcome), contradict each other in actions and decisions, forego Fadak, etc.
The success of the Holy Prophet (saw) is that he left us a model which can be re-implemented to establish justice. The failure of Wilayah is the lack of any realistic model. And the model you might ascribe to them is replete with inconsistencies and contradictions.
So who introduced justice? If the answer is that the Prophet s.a.w did then what exactly happened to that justice? You must ponder on this and accept that Caliphate is what messed things up and Saqifa was just only the beginning of things going wrong.😊
Now watch how your own idiotic statement will slap you in the face. I do not know how you can go from justice to Caliphate or Saqifa messing things up. However, if I accept your claim (that Caliphate messed things up) then
why did Imam Ali (ra) and Imam Hassan (ra) accept the Caliphate (if it was a cursed system)?
Honesty and you are polar opposites but if you were honest for one day and re-read your comments, you would see that all your allegations (in one way or another) are also accusations against your own "infallible" Imams (ra).
😊 He didn't make him the leader of the Muslims. You have no knowledge about the peace treaty.
Preceded by a stupid smiley face, thank you for proving that you are not a follower of, and will not follow, Imam Hassan (ra). I laughed out loud when I read, "He didn't make him the leader of the Muslims". Fine! Muawiya forced his way to the throne. Again, my point! Muawiya out-muscled an "infallible" Imam (ra) who possessed both worldly and outer-worldly power, lol. Muawiya must have been in a class by himself, above the Imams (ra), lol!
And staying on the topic of honesty, you accuse me of not having knowledge of the peace treaty between Imam Hassan (ra) and Muawiya and in the next post, you copy-paste the Treaty of Hudaibiyah. I am not surprised! This is how you (Shias) are programmed. They teach you "concept A" by pointing you to "concept B" which, by the way, is totally unrelated to "concept A". And so, it shows that there is a fundamental flaw in Shi'i teaching and learning centers starting with the teachers.