Incident of Thursday/Hadith of Pen and Paper/Hadith Qirtas - Yasir Qadhi Lecture

[MuslimK]

بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم

Video Title:
Seerah 103 - The 1st Rightful Khalifah of Islam Part 1: Incident of the Scrolls ~ Dr. Yasir Qadhi

[Rationalist]

I don't recall either Abi bakr or Ali using this to prove their Caliphate. Also, I haven't read Abi Bakr telling the people that him leading the prayer is indication for the Caliphate. Likewise, nowhere in history do you see Imam Ali (as) using al Ghadir as a reference to his Caliphate.

[Hani]

That's because they weren't appointed.

[Rationalist]

Exactly!

[scusemyenglish]

Slm.

Sorry I have not seen the video but I have read in the book of Othamn Khames that we know what the messenger saws should said . He has not written "how to be united" but he has finnaly said orraly.

Someone can say me more?

[MuslimK]

This is another but short way to answer the issue:

http://twelvershia.net/2016/05/03/answer-to-the-calamity-of-thursday-pen-and-paper-hadith/

[MuslimK]

Slm.

Sorry I have not seen the video but I have read in the book of Othamn Khames that we know what the messenger saws should said . He has not written "how to be united" but he has finnaly said orraly.

Someone can say me more?

I remember that as well. I think he (saw) said something like establish prayer, help the poor etc.