Marriage of Sayedna Umar (r.a) with Umm Kulthum (r.a)

[Sword of Allah]

Salam, this is a much debated topic and I have read both sides of the arguments. I like to know the following;

1) Do we have any authentic Hadiths on this topic from our books?

2) Why did the scholars disagree on which Umm Kulthum (r.a) it was?

[MuslimK]

Walaikum Salam wr wb,

Welcome to the forum.


1) Yes, we do have plenty of authentic narrations.
2) Who?

[Sword of Allah]

I came across something that said it was the daughter of Sayedna Abu Bakr (a.s)?

Can you please share these authentic Hadith and what are the grading to them?

[MuslimK]

I came across something that said it was the daughter of Sayedna Abu Bakr (a.s)?

Those are weak opinions.

Can you please share these authentic Hadith and what are the grading to them?

Check this link bro:
https://islamistruth.wordpress.com/2011/01/06/marriage-of-umarra-to-umm-kulthoum-bint-alira-sunni-version/

It is also authentically proven from Shia books.