Proving Abu Talib died as a mushrik and not as a muslim

[ahlebaitlover]

Salam brother.
Please start a thread on abu talib died as a mushrik.

[Ameen]

Salam brother.
Please start a thread on abu talib died as a mushrik.

If this is what you believe in then the Prophet (pbuh) was looked after and raised by a Mushrik or a Kafir. And what about the Prophet's (pbuh) parents??? Were they Mushriks or Kafirs too??? Was there no believers before Muhammad (pbuh) was born or before he declared and introduced himself as Messenger? What was the divine message before Muhammad (pbuh) Didn't know one believe in and follow that messege???

[Furkan]

Just ask one question, mr riddle.

[ahlebaitlover]

it would be good if you can post all sunni tafaseer or ahaadith here.

[Optimus Prime]

Salam brother.
Please start a thread on abu talib died as a mushrik.

If this is what you believe in then the Prophet (pbuh) was looked after and raised by a Mushrik or a Kafir. And what about the Prophet's (pbuh) parents??? Were they Mushriks or Kafirs too??? Was there no believers before Muhammad (pbuh) was born or before he declared and introduced himself as Messenger? What was the divine message before Muhammad (pbuh) Didn't know one believe in and follow that messege???

Abu Talib was a kafir no doubt and a loser for not accepting the deen when he prompted by the Prophet (SAW). That Mr. Ameen is a FACT according to our authentic sources.

Yes, kuddos to him for supporting the cause of his nephew (SAW), but if you don't accept the deen let alone consider it when others around him especially his OWN brothers are embracing the faith then all those efforts are in vein, I'm afraid. Hamza and Abbas ibn Abu Mutalib (RA) were winners in this regard.

Abu Talib will be in the fire of Janaham, unfortunately.

[Optimus Prime]

Salam brother.
Please start a thread on abu talib died as a mushrik.

I think this thread will suffice. No need for two threads on the same topic.