Second question for the SHias on this site

[Optimus Prime]

It is the Sunnah of Ali (RA), Hassan (RA) and Hussain (RA) to name your children Abu Bakr and Umar.

Would you ever consider naming your kids these names? Whether you feel those children of these esteemed personalities was not Abu Bakr (RA) and Umar (RA) during the Prophet (SAW) is another discussion altogether.

[Taha]

1.) Yes but

2.) No but

(^_^)

[lotfilms]

Yea i wouldn't have a problem naming my son Umar

[Optimus Prime]

Yea i wouldn't have a problem naming my son Umar

What about Abu Bakr?

[Optimus Prime]

1.) Yes but

2.) No but

(^_^)

But, what?

It was only one question. What was your second answer referring to?

[Taha]

1.) Yes but

2.) No but

(^_^)

But, what?

It was only one question. What was your second answer referring to?

It was a joke representing how Shias talk. Yes it's a sunah of Ali but (excuse). No, I wouldn't name my kids those names because (excuse).

[MuslimK]

Yea i wouldn't have a problem naming my son Umar

You are not even a (proper) Shia

[Hani]

It was a joke representing how Shias talk. Yes it's a sunah of Ali but (excuse). No, I wouldn't name my kids those names because (excuse).

Do I have a section on this in my Shia religion of excuses thread? Hmmm... All can be arranged my friend, if you request we'll make you a section for it : p

[Hani]

Yea i wouldn't have a problem naming my son Umar

If you do that while the people around you still view you as an Imami, it's gonna be a glorious scandal, make sure to film every moment of it!! Must Watch!!

[Ameen]

It is the Sunnah of Ali (RA), Hassan (RA) and Hussain (RA) to name your children Abu Bakr and Umar.

Would you ever consider naming your kids these names? Whether you feel those children of these esteemed personalities was not Abu Bakr (RA) and Umar (RA) during the Prophet (SAW) is another discussion altogether.

First one needs to look at those narrations, that mention they named their children so and so, how authentic and reliable they are. A lot went on in history to hide many things and make it look all sugar and honey.

It's surprising how you jump to clarifying authenticity about other narrations and matters but here you seem to accept things like this automatically.

[Furkan]

" but are you sure it's authentic" (add this to the excuse list :p)

[Optimus Prime]

It is the Sunnah of Ali (RA), Hassan (RA) and Hussain (RA) to name your children Abu Bakr and Umar.

Would you ever consider naming your kids these names? Whether you feel those children of these esteemed personalities was not Abu Bakr (RA) and Umar (RA) during the Prophet (SAW) is another discussion altogether.

First one needs to look at those narrations, that mention they named their children so and so, how authentic and reliable they are. A lot went on in history to hide many things and make it look all sugar and honey.

It's surprising how you jump to clarifying authenticity about other narrations and matters but here you seem to accept things like this automatically.

Same presumption bakwaas you chunter out with, seriously.

Automatically accept things? No, that's trait of a confused Rafidhi. How do you know I haven't looked up such narrations and it's grading? Again, trying to derail the thread and confuse the reader because he can't stomach the fact Ali (RA) knew [the superiority of] Abu Bakr (RA) and Umar (RA).

Next time in such threads of mine answer the question accordingly or remain [quiet].

[Ameen]

" but are you sure it's authentic" (add this to the excuse list :p)

It's got nothing to do with excuses, it's to do with principals and facts. Why not look at everything how authentic and reliable it is.

[Furkan]

You call yourself a shia wilst you don't even know the sons of your first imam. How about atleast searching it up a little bit instead of questioning everything which get's shoved in front of you.