TwelverShia.net Forum

(Question for Sunnies) What is the thing that you dislike about ahlul sunnah?

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

ShiaMan

So this includes al Kuylani and Mullah Majlisi?
Sure if they held such a belief. However narrating a quote from someone and holding the same belief are different.

La'na on whoever Ali, Fatima, Hassan and Hussain send la'na on. Is this good enough?
Well its a start... :)

The reason is 12ers do no do taqiyyah against Muawiyah and Yazid. So it has to be Umar.
What were the actions of Caliph Umar that leads you to believe it was him? Why not Caliphs Abu Bakr or Uthman? Or AR ibn Awf? etc?


Do you have detail about Ibn Taymiyah and his fatwa to kill the 12er Shia? I would like detail.
My homework then...

You want us to condemn ISIS because they make your kind out to be their enemy.  You play victim and want compensation.  That is a Western tactic.  The West expects Muslims to condemn a non-Muslim entity just because it (once in a while) attacks their kind.  We, on the other hand, condemn ISIS because they are contradict Islamic principles of peace, justice and humanity.
Wrong, I want you to condemn ISIS because they portray Islam and the Prophet in a negative light. We are neither looking for your sympathies not need compensation from you. Slightly off topic but nevertheless relevant, how come the bastions of Islam Saudi/UAE/Qatar/Kuwait have not taken in any refuges from Syria and Iraq? Turkey has, Lebanon has and even Jordan.

Don't need your approval!  I do it as my service towards Islam, not to please the Shia or the West.
I am not giving you my approval but simply lauding your actions whatever your intentions may have been.


Rationalist


Sure if they held such a belief. However narrating a quote from someone and holding the same belief are different.
Well there is quote from Mullah Majalisi were he accepted that are 17,000 verses in the Quran and he authenticated it. The 12er Shia scholar are silent on the issue. They do not draw a judgement that the current Quran we have, whoever considers it incomplete is a non-Muslim. Are you really going head and saying such people deserve la'na? Or are you thinking in your mind that the 12th Imam's Quran is real complete version and that's the one which complete?

Quote
Well its a start... :)
Prophet Yusuf's (as) brother were his enemies but there is no proof that he cursed them. So likewise, I will have to accept what is sunnah and not what our conclusions say about who deserves la'na.

Quote
What were the actions of Caliph Umar that leads you to believe it was him? Why not Caliphs Abu Bakr or Uthman? Or AR ibn Awf? etc?
The reason is your sect believes Umar killed Fatima (sa) which if it was true makes him even worst than Yazid.



My homework then...
You are aware he lived in the time of Al Qami who worked with Mongals and told them to invade Iraq. In return they Mongals killed over 1.6 millions Iraqis. Then in return Al Qami was promoted as well.



muslim720

Wrong, I want you to condemn ISIS because they portray Islam and the Prophet in a negative light. We are neither looking for your sympathies not need compensation from you. Slightly off topic but nevertheless relevant, how come the bastions of Islam Saudi/UAE/Qatar/Kuwait have not taken in any refuges from Syria and Iraq? Turkey has, Lebanon has and even Jordan.

I am used to you derailing discussions but neither am I Saudi, nor Emirati and I am not Kuwaiti either.  It does not tick me off as much when you derail discussions or put the onus on us (to chase your red-herrings).  It infuriates me when I see you build a premise - like declaring Saudi Arabia, UAE and Kuwait bastions of Islam - and then posing a question to me (regarding those countries not taking in refugees)?  Did I declare them bastions of Islam?  No!  Do I consider them bastions of Islam?  No!  You build your own premises and then attack them to make it appear as though you are refuting us.  In reality, you are deceiving yourself and learning_boy (or whatever his username is)!
"Our coward ran from those in authority" - Iceman (admitting the truth regarding his 12th Imam)

Mythbuster1

You should condemn all the LIARS in history of Shiite Islam for they PORTRAY ISLAM AND PROPHET SAW in a negative light😜

Shiitism came before Isis

So come along now condemn them liars of hidden living imams, the liars of divine Imamate false concepts, the liars who say mutah wasn't banned, the liars who curse the wives and friends.......condemn them killers who kill on the basis of the above, get sissytani and nakshajawani to get the ball rolling

Otherwise your talking from your rear end😉👍

 

Related Topics

  Subject / Started by Replies Last post
4 Replies
1612 Views
Last post May 04, 2015, 01:26:30 AM
by Optimus Prime
31 Replies
4849 Views
Last post August 01, 2016, 09:15:52 PM
by ShiaMan
29 Replies
4617 Views
Last post July 13, 2016, 06:57:50 PM
by ShiaMan
12 Replies
1791 Views
Last post July 15, 2016, 02:05:24 PM
by fgss