TwelverShia.net Forum

Sunni Shia Discussion Forum => Quran-Tafseer => Topic started by: Farid on September 11, 2017, 06:03:59 AM

Title: Hud 46
Post by: Farid on September 11, 2017, 06:03:59 AM
Bismillah,

So, I stumbled upon an authentic narration in Uyoon Akhbar Al-Redha 2/82 in which Al-Redha asks, "How do they recite this verse (Hud 46) about the son of Nuh?

He (the narrator) said: They read it in two ways:

إنه عَمَلٌ غَيْرُ صالح
إنه عَمِلَ غَيْرَ صالح

The Imam responded, "They lie! He is his son, but Allah removed him when he went against his religion."


Commentary:
Al-Redha rejects the first recitation as an invalid recitation since it means "He is not a good deed" and accepts the second recitation that says, "He committed a bad deed."

I would like to point out that the first recitation is recited by all Shias today. ;)
Title: Re: Hud 46
Post by: Hadrami on September 13, 2017, 09:45:05 AM
rejected the recitation, but did he tell them to keep reciting the wrong one?
Title: Re: Hud 46
Post by: Farid on September 13, 2017, 09:35:02 PM
Apparently Shias are supposed to recite like Sunnis until the Qa'im comes.
Title: Re: Hud 46
Post by: Hadrami on September 14, 2017, 01:36:07 AM
Apparently Shias are supposed to recite like Sunnis until the Qa'im comes.
imam told them to recite invalid ayat. What an imam of (mis)guidance 😁
Title: Re: Hud 46
Post by: Abu Muhammad on September 14, 2017, 04:52:03 PM
Bismillah,

So, I stumbled upon an authentic narration in Uyoon Akhbar Al-Redha 2/82 in which Al-Redha asks, "How do they recite this verse (Hud 46) about the son of Nuh?

He (the narrator) said: They read it in two ways:

إنه عَمَلٌ غَيْرُ صالح
إنه عَمِلَ غَيْرَ صالح

The Imam responded, "They lie! He is his son, but Allah removed him when he went against his religion."


Commentary:
Al-Redha rejects the first recitation as an invalid recitation since it means "He is not a good deed" and accepts the second recitation that says, "He committed a bad deed."

I would like to point out that the first recitation is recited by all Shias today. ;)

Did any of their scholars say that the imam was doing taqiyyah?
Title: Re: Hud 46
Post by: Farid on September 14, 2017, 05:04:59 PM
I am not aware of that.